Facebook File Instagram LinkedIn
← Resources

MSA vs. NDA: Differences, timing, and when to use each

Suppose you’re about to work with a counterparty that wants to share sensitive information with you. You’ll likely sign an NDA to protect it.

But a couple of weeks later, after both sides agree to move forward, you receive an MSA. As you read through it, you notice the MSA includes its own confidentiality clause. Is the NDA you already signed redundant? What is the function of this new document, and how will it affect your business?

This guide explains why NDAs and MSAs are essential but distinct tools in a commercial relationship. We’ll break down the purpose and structure of each agreement and discuss the risks of assuming that you only need one or the other.

What are MSAs and NDAs?

A master services agreement (MSA) is a contract marking the beginning of a commercial relationship. This agreement defines the terms for the engagement that follows, including:

  • The services to be provided and payment structure
  • The use of proprietary information
  • Liability limitations
  • Dispute resolution procedures

Each project the parties undertake is defined with a separate statement of work (SOW) with project-specific deadlines, fees, deliverables, and acceptance criteria. The SOWs remain governed by the MSA.

In contrast, a nondisclosure agreement (NDA) is a confidentiality contract designed to protect proprietary or sensitive information from being disclosed to third parties. NDAs define what information is confidential, how the receiving party may use it and for how long, and the consequences for breaching confidentiality.

Companies may sign an MSA, an NDA, or both in the early stages of a commercial engagement, but they are not interchangeable. Each addresses distinct concerns in different ways.

Key differences between MSAs and NDAs

MSAs and NDAs differ structurally and substantively. The former governs a commercial engagement, while the latter addresses confidentiality.

MSAs are broad documents, covering:

  1. The scope of work and each party’s role, including the services to be provided and payment structures.
  2. Who owns the work product of the collaboration, often including provisions for background IP (e.g., whether it’s licensed or transferred) and for establishing ownership in case the relationship ends before a project is finished.
  3. Confidentiality provisions, though these clauses are often narrower and less detailed than a separate NDA.
  4. Risk-limiting mechanisms, such as warranties and indemnification clauses
  5. The jurisdiction for resolving disputes.
  6. Liability caps, which commonly limit damages to the total fees paid under the agreement.
  7. Options for renewal or termination.

MSAs are usually negotiated once, at the start of a business relationship with recurring work, rather than on a per-project basis.

An NDA's scope is narrower by design, limited to establishing each party's confidentiality obligations. NDAs define what constitutes confidential information and how the receiving party may use it.

NDAs usually establish:

  • Information to be excluded, such as public information or information already disclosed between the parties.
  • A clear term and duration of confidentiality obligations, commonly two to five years. (In some cases, the expectation of confidentiality lasts beyond the end of the relationship, even indefinitely, e.g., in the case of trade secrets).
  • Procedures for the end of the relationship, such as the return or destruction of confidential materials.
  • Remedies for breach of the agreement.

NDAs may be mutual, extending to both parties, or unilateral, binding only the receiving party to non-disclosure obligations.

When to use an NDA vs. an MSA

NDAs and MSAs address distinct needs at different points of a business relationship. The question isn’t which one to use; it’s when to use each, and whether you need both.

When to use an NDA

NDAs protect sensitive information without committing the parties to move forward with a relationship. For that reason, companies often use them when evaluating potential collaborations, whether a vendor or another business, or during due diligence ahead of an acquisition. If you anticipate sharing proprietary information during investor pitches or the RFP process, an NDA can help protect your strategy and IP. The same applies when onboarding employees, contractors, and others who may have access to sensitive information.

Although all industries can use NDAs, they are especially common in healthcare, tech, legal services, and finance, where trade secrets, intellectual property, and client information are regularly exchanged.

When to use an MSA

MSAs help mark the formal beginning of a long-term business relationship. They are especially common in vendor or customer engagements that involve recurring projects or multiple statements of work. MSAs can also help set clear expectations for the legal and operational details of a business partnership, especially in regulated industries where documentation is key to meeting compliance requirements and avoiding liability.

When both are appropriate

It’s not uncommon for companies to sign both an NDA and an MSA within a single partnership.

Consider a growth-stage company looking for a vendor to provide a new CRM platform. Before sharing any internal data or customer volume metrics with potential SaaS vendors, the company requires each to sign an NDA. After the evaluation period, the company presents its chosen vendor with an MSA that sets out the terms of a multi-year licensing relationship, including provisions on permitted data use, IP rights for any customized tools, and liability for downtime.

Signing order

Companies usually sign NDAs while they evaluate a potential business relationship. If they move forward, the relationship is formalized with an MSA.

After the MSA is signed, the NDA typically continues in parallel, covering information shared during the pre-MSA period until the end of the stated term—unless the MSA specifies a time at which another internal confidentiality clause takes precedence.

For many companies today, an initial NDA followed by an MSA is the practical way to approach a long-term business relationship. That said, companies can also enter into NDAs after signing an MSA. For example, if the scope of work drifts from the initial MSA or if there is a joint diligence request between existing partners, the parties can draft an NDA.

Can an NDA be part of an MSA?

While not NDAs per se, MSAs often include confidentiality provisions covering information exchanged during the engagement.

However, many of these clauses don't cover sensitive information shared during the evaluation or pitch stage before the relationship formally begins. That’s why it’s wise to have a separate, confidentiality-specific agreement—particularly when evaluating different vendors or partners, or when disclosing IP and other business-critical information before an MSA is signed.

Although the MSA protects confidentiality during the ongoing relationship, the NDA can be key to protecting what you share before the relationship begins.

Common pitfalls to avoid

Misunderstanding the purpose of MSAs and NDAs can expose companies to avoidable risks.

Relying on an NDA alone leaves a company without documented expectations around critical legal or operational details, from payment structures for individual SOWs and deliverables acceptance criteria to liability. Without an MSA to define IP ownership, any work independent contractors produce may remain theirs by default under federal law; changing this after the fact can be time-consuming and costly.

On the other hand, relying solely on an MSA without a prior NDA leaves sensitive information shared pre-signing at risk of exposure. Many MSA confidentiality clauses are drafted narrowly to cover only information disclosed after signing. Additionally, MSAs built on generic templates often miss deal-specific details, such as state-level legal requirements or enforceability concerns unique to an industry or project.

In any of these scenarios, the underlying problem is the same: treating these contracts as interchangeable formalities without understanding how they meet your engagement’s specific needs.

Crosby reviews your MSAs and NDAs

As companies grow, so does the stack of MSAs and NDAs needed to manage a growing network of vendor, customer, investor, and partner relationships. As standard as these documents are, they deserve serious review, since each one can significantly affect your company’s IP, liability, operational flexibility, and more.

AI-native law firm Crosby helps your growing business keep pace. Crosby’s custom-built agents use market data and your preferences to take the first pass on contract redlines, and barred attorneys oversee the work. Median turnaround time is less than six hours, and Crosby charges transparent flat fees.

Talk to Crosby about your next commercial contract.

FAQ

What happens if an NDA or MSA is breached?

Generally, breaching an NDA or an MSA can lead to legal action, potential financial penalties, and often the end of the business relationship. Many NDAs allow injunctive relief to prevent the continued spread of sensitive information, while an MSA breach can trigger indemnification obligations or end the contract.

Are MSAs and NDAs enforceable globally?

This largely depends on the jurisdiction. In the US, they usually are, but international enforceability can depend on whether local courts recognize jurisdiction and whether the terms align with local laws.

How does technology help manage multiple MSAs and NDAs?

Contract lifecycle management (CLM) platforms can provide a centralized tool for companies to store and track documents across commercial relationships. Many of these platforms are designed to reduce the administrative burden of managing these contracts by automating repetitive tasks (e.g., seeking signatures or approvals), helping standardize language across contracts, and tracking deadlines and renewal dates.

Should small businesses use MSAs and NDAs?

Small businesses concerned about managing long-term vendor relationships, protecting intellectual property, or ensuring compliance stand to benefit from NDAs and MSAs in their commercial partnerships. More important than a business's size are its operational needs and potential risk exposure.