Your growing company required a potential partner to sign an NDA during diligence, but the deal fell through. A few months later, you discover the company used the information it learned during diligence to build a competing offering. Can you enforce the NDA in court? What does an NDA need to say for the courts to uphold it?
This guide explains what makes a commercial NDA enforceable. It also covers state laws that can affect whether courts will enforce your company’s NDA and how they interpret its terms.
What makes an NDA enforceable?
Nondisclosure agreements (NDAs) are governed by contract law. Courts weigh several key drafting points when enforcing them.
In general, enforceable contracts must include:
- Mutual assent: Both parties agree to the terms.
- Consideration: Each party offers something of value (in commercial NDAs, consideration typically consists of sharing information in exchange for the other party’s promise to keep it confidential and not use it outside the purpose for which it was shared).
- Definite terms: Clear and specific terms that a court can interpret.
- Lawful purpose: The agreement’s purpose and terms must be legal.
An enforceable NDA also requires:
- A defined scope: What is considered confidential and what is excluded. An NDA often protects proprietary data, trade secrets, financial information, customer lists, and other confidential data defined in the agreement.
- Receiving party obligations: How this party must protect and handle the information.
- Reasonable restrictions: The NDA can’t restrict the receiver’s lawful business activities beyond what’s needed to protect confidential information.
Enforcement is easier when the NDA includes a remedy for a breach, such as liquidated damages or injunctive relief. A remedy clause is not required for the contract to be valid, but it clarifies what the receiving party owes if the agreement is violated.
When an NDA may not hold up in court
NDA enforcement problems arise when the agreement includes unreasonable restrictions, unlawful terms, or vague or overbroad language. In addition, some states limit what NDAs can cover, and courts can strike down certain clauses or the entire agreement if those rules are violated.
Overbroad or vague terms
Vague or overbroad definitions of confidential information can render an NDA unenforceable. In 2020, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit refused to enforce nondisclosure provisions that defined confidential information as “all information” about the company’s business methods, clients, and procedures. The court called out the NDA’s “astounding breadth and lack of any meaningful limitation” and ruled it unenforceable. Courts are more likely to enforce NDAs that cover only the information the disclosing party needs to protect.
Illegal or public-policy restrictions
NDAs may not lawfully bar whistleblowing to regulators, reports to government agencies, or responses to subpoenas. They also can’t prohibit reporting unlawful conduct to authorities. Any such term in an NDA is unenforceable, regardless of what other terms the NDA includes.
Courts usually strike an unlawful clause and enforce the remainder of the contract if the unenforceable clause is not central to the agreement. However, a defect in the NDA’s core terms can be fatal to the entire agreement.
Contract formation problems
As with any contract, an NDA must be properly formed to be enforceable. In commercial deals, formation problems often arise from practical errors. For example, the agreement names the wrong entity (e.g., a subsidiary instead of the parent company), the parties exchange multiple drafts and redlined versions but sign different final drafts, or the person signing for one party has no actual or apparent authority to bind the company.
State laws that can override an NDA
State law regulating NDAs focuses more on employment agreements than business-to-business agreements. Several states void terms in employment and settlement agreements that prevent people from disclosing harassment and discrimination.
For commercial NDAs, a choice-of-law clause usually determines which state’s law applies, and a forum selection clause determines where disputes will be heard. State laws vary in how they treat restraints on trade and the duration of confidentiality obligations. Trade secret protection also depends on the applicable jurisdiction.
Here are a few examples of state laws affecting NDAs:
- California courts closely review NDAs that restrict business activity to determine whether the terms unreasonably restrain trade. If an NDA is broad enough to restrict the receiving party’s normal business, its validity may be challenged there.
- While most states don’t regulate the duration of an NDA’s confidentiality obligations, Georgia allows them to last as long as the information remains confidential in certain franchise, distribution, and sale-of-business agreements. However, short confidentiality periods can backfire for trade secret owners. Two federal courts (Silicon Image v. Analogix Semiconductor and D.B. Riley v. AB Engineering) have ruled that a short-term NDA obligation weakens a trade secret claim because it suggests the owner did not treat the information as a true secret.
- Most states adhere to the Uniform Trade Secrets Act, which defines what counts as a trade secret and how to prove misappropriation. New York, however, still applies common law, which holds to different standards. If an NDA dispute involves trade secrets, a case governed by New York law may require different proof and offer different remedies than one in a UTSA state.
- States usually follow the choice-of-law designated by the parties in an NDA. New York and Delaware will honor the choice-of-law designation even when little connection to the state exists. Commercial NDAs often designate New York or Delaware law to take advantage of this flexibility.
How courts handle NDA breaches
When a court finds an enforceable NDA was breached, remedies typically include monetary damages to compensate proven losses, injunctive relief, and attorneys’ fees if the NDA provides for them.
The most difficult part of winning relief in an NDA lawsuit isn’t proving the breach; it’s determining quantifiable damages. As a result, many well-drafted commercial NDAs include a liquidated damages clause that sets a predetermined amount the breaching party must pay.
Beyond monetary damages, courts can also issue injunctive relief: an order requiring the breaching party to stop disclosing or using the information. Strong NDAs include injunctive relief language to help courts grant this remedy swiftly.
If the NDA lacks a liquidated damages or injunctive relief clause, companies that suffered a breach may choose not to file suit. Given the indeterminate nature of damages attributable to the breach, combined with mounting attorneys' fees, recovering more than litigation costs can seem unlikely.
How long an NDA lasts
The duration of an NDA depends on two factors: the duration of the confidentiality obligation and the general term of the agreement. These are two different clocks that often run on different schedules. An NDA may last one year while the confidentiality obligation survives for another three, five, or 10 years after that.
The confidentiality obligation itself can be structured in a few common ways:
- Fixed terms: Confidentiality obligations last for a defined term, usually two to five years after the agreement expires or is terminated. This is called the survival period.
- Trigger-based endings: Confidentiality obligations end when the information becomes public through permitted means or when a specific business event occurs.
- Ongoing confidentiality obligations: Confidentiality obligations continue indefinitely, especially for trade secrets, as long as the information remains secret.
Crosby handles commercial contract review
Commercial NDAs are part of the routine contract volume for growing companies — from vendor onboarding to partnership discussions. An NDA’s enforceability depends on its scope, drafting, and the applicable state law.
Crosby reviews commercial NDAs at signing, applies your company’s playbook standards to improve enforceability, and flags terms courts might not uphold.
Crosby's custom-built agents use market data and your preferences to redline contracts, with a barred attorney in the loop. Median turnaround time is under six hours, and Crosby charges transparent, upfront, flat fees.
Talk to Crosby about your next commercial contract.
FAQs
What makes a commercial NDA most likely to hold up in court?
Courts typically uphold NDAs with a defined scope of confidential information, exclusions for public information, legally compelled disclosure, and independently developed information. Other requirements include clearly identified parties with authority to sign and a properly executed agreement. Enforcement problems typically involve overbroad or vague language.
Can an NDA cover information that becomes public?
An NDA cannot protect information that has become lawfully public. NDAs, instead, provide one party with a claim against another that disclosed information in violation of the agreement.
What should a company do if an NDA has been breached?
Preserve all evidence of a breach immediately, including dated correspondence and other communication relating to any disclosure. Review the NDA for available remedies, notice requirements, and dispute-resolution provisions. Contact counsel immediately; injunctive relief remedies depend on swift action to mitigate potential damages.

