In some companies, there’s no structured process around contract review.
A vendor MSA lands in the legal team's inbox. A lawyer picks it up when they can, scans it against what they remember from the playbook, and sends redlines back to the business team, which asks follow-up questions in Slack. Some get answered; some don't. A liability exception comes up, and no one is sure who has authority to approve it. Eventually, someone signs.
Teams can only work this way for so long. As contract volume increases, contracts pile up.
A modern commercial contract review workflow moves agreements through defined stages, each with a clear owner and purpose. Here’s a close look at how contract review works.
The stages of a modern contract review process
Most contract management and review workflows follow seven broad stages:
- Intake: The agreement enters the contract review workflow.
- Triage: The contract is categorized by contract type, risk, value, and urgency.
- Review: Legal compares the terms against company standards to identify potential problems.
- Redline: Proposed changes are drafted.
- Negotiate: The parties work through any disputed terms.
- Approve and sign: Internal stakeholders approve exceptions. Authorized signatories execute the agreement.
- Archive: The final contract and its relevant metadata are stored for future use.
The stages are straightforward. But contracts can stall in the gaps between stages. For instance, a contract might idle after intake. Or redlines might be drafted but not reviewed or sent. That’s why clear handoffs and ownership at each stage are critical.
Intake and triage
Intake is how contracts enter the commercial contract review process. Your company size usually determines how this looks: At a small company with few incoming contracts, it can be as simple as emailing an agreement to a designated recipient.
But higher contract volumes usually mean more complicated intake processes. These often involve contract request forms, sales tools, contract software, procurement systems, and similar structured intake channels.
The intake process can take many forms, but the goal is always to route the contract to the appropriate place. To do that, you typically need some standard intake information:
- Contract type
- Contract value
- Scope of work (SOW)
- Counterparty
- Business owner
- Data or security implications
- Whether it’s company paper or counterparty paper
- Requested signing date
Triage follows intake. This can happen manually or via rules built into contracting software. In either case, the triage process matches the contract with the right level of review before legal work begins.
A multiyear customer agreement will almost certainly take a different review path from a standard NDA. A business-critical SaaS agreement involving sensitive customer data also needs more review than a low-value vendor contract with standard terms.
Triage is where you decide which path a contract type takes. It’s also where a lot of contract review processes start to break down. When agreements arrive without basic context or through five different channels, reviewers waste time chasing information.
Review and redline
The main contract work starts in the review stage. This is where a reviewer checks the agreement against the company’s preferred positions, contracting playbook, business context, and past agreements. That often means taking a deep look at the following provisions, perhaps with the help of a standardized checklist that enables consistent review across stakeholders:
- Warranties
- Renewal terms
- Termination rights
- Payment terms
- Confidentiality clauses
- Data protection provisions
- Force majeure
- Intellectual property concerns
- Limitation of liability clauses
- Indemnification clauses
- Dispute resolution
This review turns up issues. The redlining stage turns those issues into edits.
The review and redline stages are increasingly well suited to AI assistance. When reviewing against a defined playbook, flagging deviations, identifying relevant clauses, and writing redlines, AI can take a solid first pass at all of that much faster than a human can.
That’s not to say, however, that no humans are needed. The opposite is true. Human judgment and validation remain as important as ever in AI-enabled contract workflows. For example, AI might identify that a liability cap in the contract differs from the company’s preferred position, but a human lawyer can go deeper, apply context, and evaluate whether the deviation matters for this deal or whether another provision shifts the analysis.
Negotiation, approval, signing, and archiving
Redlines go back to the counterparty, and negotiation begins. The counterparty accepts or rejects each redline, sometimes putting forward alternative language. It’s an iterative process where each round raises new questions that call for input from legal and business stakeholders.
The risk is creating bottlenecks. Clear escalation rules reduce that risk. For instance, your playbook might allow a reviewer to accept certain fallback positions without additional approval. Meanwhile, compliance-sensitive provisions might require approval from an executive or legal leadership.
Payment schedule disputes might go to finance. Data commitments might go to security and privacy departments, and pricing and vendor requirements to procurement. The idea is to have the right people reviewing to keep negotiations moving as smoothly as possible.
Once the parties have agreed on everything, the contract goes through the signature process.
But execution isn’t the end. Strong contract review processes provide for accessible storage of final agreements. The goal is to capture relevant metadata such as term, renewal date, notice periods, contract owner, and key obligations so you can manage the relationship after signing.
Who handles which parts of the process?
The contract review process involves more than the legal team. Business owners request contracts, provide commercial context, and often handle intake (perhaps with the help of administrative personnel). A designated workflow owner or someone on legal ops handles routing and triage. From there, legal handles review.
Legal review processes vary by an organization's size and stage. For example, at smaller companies, in-house counsel may handle everything, or outside counsel may be on retainer for contract work. At larger organizations with higher contract volume, legal review may take a multifaceted approach, relying on a combination of the following resources:
- In-house counsel: Strategic agreements, high-stakes negotiations, unusual risk, and matters that involve heavy business context.
- Outside counsel: Specialized, high-value, complex, or unusual agreements where outside expertise helps.
- AI-native law firms: Recurring commercial contract volume where agreements follow patterns but still need lawyer review.
- Self-serve workflows and templates: Low-risk, repeatable boilerplate agreements that fit squarely into well-defined company standards.
There’s plenty of overlap among these categories. For instance, a standard vendor agreement might begin with an AI-assisted review process followed by validation from an attorney. Meanwhile, in-house or outside counsel might be the point of contact on a major strategic partnership. Some routine or boilerplate agreements, such as a self-serve software use agreement, might not need any negotiation.
How to tell if the contract review process is working
Several metrics can give you insight into how well your process is working:
- Contract cycle time: Measures the time from intake to completed legal review or signature.
- Time to first review: Determines how long contracts wait before the substantive work begins.
- Contracts by risk or type: Shows whether your legal resources are concentrating on the contract types that need them most.
- Turnaround by contract type: Distinguishes process delays from truly complex and time-consuming legal work.
- Escalation frequency: Shows whether your contracting playbook gives reviewers enough authority or escalates too many routine decisions.
- Playbook deviation patterns: Shows when the company’s standard playbook position no longer reflects how it contracts, especially when the same provisions are negotiated on almost every contract.
- Approval delays: Points out whether contracts are getting bogged down after legal review rather than in the middle of it.
- Resource allocation: Demonstrates whether your legal resources are concentrating on the contract types that need them most.
Importantly, you don’t need to track all of these metrics at once. Each measures a different type of process problem, and tracking the ones relevant to your system’s issues is most likely to surface useful baseline data and provide context for improvement.
Crosby handles the high-volume contract layer
For growing companies, most contract volume is commercial paper that follows predictable patterns: vendor MSAs, customer agreements, DPAs, contractor NDAs. Crosby handles that layer.
Crosby’s custom-built AI agents use market data and your preferences to take the first pass on contract redlines, and barred attorneys oversee the work. Median turnaround time is under six hours, and Crosby bills transparent, upfront flat fees.
Talk to Crosby about your next commercial contract.
FAQs
What are the most common bottlenecks in contract review?
Common sources of delay are intake problems, unclear approval paths, inconsistent contracting standards, and unclear escalation rules. Contracts wait longer when it’s unclear who the right reviewer is or when key information or internal approvals are missing. Clear ownership, playbooks, escalation rules, and intake channels help prevent those bottlenecks.
How long does a typical contract review take?
Contract review time depends on complexity. Standard commercial agreements may fly through a streamlined process in hours or a day or two. But complex, unusual, heavily negotiated, or high-value agreements can take much longer.
If routine commercial contracts are frequently taking more than a week, that signals the contract review process may be creating delays, rather than the complexity of legal review itself.
Do we need a contract lifecycle management (CLM) tool to have a good contract review process?
Contract lifecycle management (CLM) software isn’t essential to a solid contract review process. It’s true that CLMs can automate intake, routing, approvals, version control, storage, and other parts of the contract process, but the underlying review process doesn’t depend on having CLM deliverables in the mix.
With shared storage, standardized intake, defined approval paths, clear ownership, checklists, and playbooks, smaller teams can operate effective contract workflows without a CLM. But as contract volume increases, a CLM can make it easier to scale those kinds of contract management processes.
Where does AI fit into the contract review process?
AI most commonly fits into the contract review process during a first-pass review. AI can read agreements against your contracting playbook to surface deviations and draft redlines. Before those redlines go back to the counterparty, an attorney can review and edit the AI’s work. This division of labor hands the repetitive part to the software and keeps the final review and legal judgment with the lawyer.

