After weeks of going back and forth about liability caps and confidentiality carve-outs, you’re approaching the end of this phase of the deal. The counterparty says it’s ready to sign, but only after they follow up with blacklines.
You’ve done enough rounds of contract negotiations to know what a redline is. But a blackline is unfamiliar. Is it the same thing as a redline? Or is it a different format that your team should have been using all along?
Like a redline, a blackline is a key part of contract negotiation. They both reflect changes made to contracts, but each has a different scope. This article covers the significance of both redlines and blacklines, when to use each, the risks associated, and how AI changes the workflow.
What are redlines, blacklines, and clean versions?
A contract redline is an edit or insertion made to a version of a contract, while a blackline is a document that shows the differences between versions. Some firms use the terms “redline” and “blackline” interchangeably, or use one term to refer to both. Technically, they mean two different things within a commercial context.
Redline
A redline is an edit (deletion, insertion, comment, strikethrough, etc.) or any change made to a legal contract, historically using a different color (red ink/red pens) to mark differences between old and new texts. Colors help distinguish between contract editors, particularly in word processors.
Contract redlining can refer to specific changes made to a working document or to the general process of marking up a document.
Blackline
A blackline is a comparison document that shows the net changes between one version and another—usually, but not always, between the latest version and the one just preceding it. The blackline shows differences in text and formatting but doesn’t highlight individual edits made between the two versions.
What’s a clean version?
A clean version is a ready-to-go draft that has already integrated or rejected any changes. The clean version is easier to read because it doesn’t have the multicolored markups that indicate text was added, changed, or deleted.
Side-by-side version comparison
Blackline, redline, and clean versions offer different ways to view a negotiated contract. The clean version shows the final text, redlines show the full edit history, and blacklines show net changes. Each format answers a different question for a different reviewer, so the right format depends on what you need to know about the negotiated contract.
Key differences between redline and blackline
Here are some key differences between contract redlines and blacklines in document review workflows:
- Purpose: Redlines highlight specific terms being actively negotiated, while blacklines make it easier to verify net changes between versions.
- Visibility of changes: Redlines show every revision made to a version of a contract, while blacklines show net changes, without the full revision history.
- Readability: A redlined document can be visually chaotic (especially with multiple negotiators). A blacklined document is easier to parse because it only shows net differences.
- Review speed: Blacklines are faster to review because the reader only sees what’s changed. A redline takes longer because you have to comb through each edit.
- Audit-trail depth: Redlines preserve the full edit history of who changed what and when, while a blackline only captures a snapshot comparison.
If the contract reviewer is answering the question, “What’s been changed in this round?” look to the redlines. But if they want to know what’s different from the previously approved version, check a blackline.
When to use redlines or blacklines in contract review
Whether you use a redline or a blackline depends on where you are in the contract review or negotiation process. Specifically, redlines fit active drafting and negotiating when parties are suggesting and accepting (or rejecting) changes, while blacklines are useful at the end of negotiation before signing.
Who should review each format?
Since redlines are edits made to contracts under active negotiation, the best people to review them are negotiators, in-house or outside counsel, and anyone else involved in the back-and-forth of getting legal, financial, and risk-allocation terms right.
Blacklines, on the other hand, are best reviewed by those who need to see net changes without actively combing through individual edits. These team members include executives, procurement, approvers, and risk reviewers.
Where each fits in the workflow
After a contract is drafted and shared, redlining begins. Each party takes turns marking up the contract—accepting, rejecting, and commenting on changes made in turn. Once the parties come to an agreement, they produce a clean version.
A blackline compares the clean version against the last approved version to confirm no new terms slipped in between rounds. That clears the contract for signature.
Practical contract-review scenarios
Here are some common contract review scenarios in which you might use redlines or blacklines:
- Counterparty edits: Counterparties use redlines to propose changes to contracts.
- Stakeholder feedback: Internal team members such as executives, risk managers, or sales leaders use redlines to share suggestions.
- Executive approval: Executives use blacklines to get a high-level view of contract changes.
- Pre-signature verification: Parties use blacklines to easily check if terms are accurate and acceptable by comparing a final contract version to one they most recently approved.
- Comparing two drafts: Word processors such as Microsoft Word can create a redlined document from two files, with inline markups with tracked changes—in other words, a blackline (in Word, Review > Compare). The resulting redlined version includes additions, deletions, and formatting changes between the two documents, without showing who made each edit or when. CLM and contract review tools can also compare two documents into a single blacklined version and add metadata about what changed. The markup looks like a redline, but it only shows net changes.
Common risks and review mistakes
Thinking of redlines and blacklines as interchangeable can create process problems that ramp up risk. Some common mistakes include:
- Source-of-truth confusion: When redlines and blacklines aren’t handled carefully (multiple files with the same name or mislabeled version numbers, for example), it’s hard to tell which document is current or who changed what and when.
- Internal markup leaking externally: If redlines aren’t carefully managed, you could end up accidentally sharing confidential comments that weaken your negotiating position.
- Visual clutter in redlines: When redlines linger after multiple rounds of negotiation, it can become difficult to determine who made what changes and easier to miss material changes buried in formatting edits.
- Format inconsistencies: A redline from one party and a blackline from another in the same negotiation round can make it difficult to compare versions.
Advanced technology doesn’t remove these risks. In fact, when used improperly, sophisticated tools shift the risk to version-control hygiene and workflow discipline.
How AI changes redlining and blacklining
AI can help make both redlining and blacklining a smoother, more efficient process. In fact, AI changes some of the mechanics of both processes without changing the outcomes each delivers.
For instance, AI-assisted redlining, which is becoming more common, allows teams to spend less time on initial contract review by letting AI agents take the first pass on an agreement, flagging deviations from playbooks or standard terms. Likewise, AI can summarize changes between versions, outline which terms moved and whether or not they’re favorable to your overall position.
AI can also integrate redlining and blacklining into wider contract management software workflows. When it identifies nonstandard terms, AI can notify specific stakeholders, trigger alerts to change certain clauses, and route the redlined (or blacklined) contract to the appropriate reviewer.
AI can speed up the negotiation process in the contract lifecycle, but it’s still important to keep a human in the loop. The AI handles the first pass and surfaces what matters, but decisions on acceptance, pushback, or escalation stay with the people overseeing the deal.
Crosby handles the commercial contract review layer
Redlines and blacklines are the working formats of commercial contract review.
Crosby’s custom-built agents use market data and your preferences to take the first pass on contract redlines, while attorneys supervise the work. Median turnaround time is under six hours, and Crosby charges transparent, upfront fees.

